Can God Change? Exploring Divine Perfection and Omniscience

[en]

Introduction: Can an Omniscient God Change His Mind?

The question of whether God can change His mind has intrigued theologians and philosophers for centuries. It raises deep questions about God’s nature, particularly His omniscience and perfection. If God knows everything, including His future actions, what basis would there be for Him to change His mind? In this article, we explore whether an all-knowing, perfect God could ever change and what implications this has for understanding divine nature.

The Argument Against God Changing His Mind

The argument that God cannot change His mind is grounded in the belief that God is omniscient—He knows everything, including the future. As an all-knowing being, God possesses foreknowledge of not only what His creations will do but also of His own actions. This concept suggests that God already knows all the future propositions about His decisions, such as “God will part the Red Sea,” and their truth value.
Given this, there is no new information or reason that could prompt God to reconsider or adjust His decisions. The notion of changing one’s mind is inherently tied to ignorance—a state where one does not have all the necessary information to make a decision. However, because God is omniscient and free from ignorance, He has no need to change His mind.

Why Changing One’s Mind Suggests Imperfection

If changing one’s mind is rooted in a prior lack of knowledge, then it could be seen as an imperfection. A being who changes their mind must first have made a decision based on incomplete or flawed information. They then acquire new knowledge, leading them to revise their decision. For humans, this can be an improvement, as it brings their thinking in line with reality.
However, in the case of a perfect being like God, such a process would imply prior imperfection. If God is already perfect in knowledge and wisdom, there is no ignorance to overcome. Therefore, changing His mind would not be a sign of progress but rather an indication that His prior knowledge was lacking, which contradicts the concept of divine omniscience.

God’s Acts of Grace: Creation and Salvation

Although the idea of change might imply improvement for finite beings like us, it does not apply to God. As a perfect being, God does not improve or gain new qualities. This raises the question: Why did God create the universe and human beings if it did not benefit Him?
The answer lies in the concept of divine grace. Creation, much like salvation, is viewed as an act of grace from God. It is not done to improve or enhance God’s nature, as He is already infinitely perfect. Instead, God creates for the benefit of His creatures, offering them the opportunity to come into relationship with Him. Through this relationship, humans experience growth and improvement, while God remains unchanged in His perfection.

Does Creation Change God?

Some might wonder whether the act of creating the universe and interacting with human beings changes God in any way. After all, as humans develop and form closer relationships with God, it might seem that His experience or existence is somehow enhanced.
However, this is not the case. God’s perfection means that He does not become more loving, more knowledgeable, or more powerful as a result of creation. His act of creation is purely for the benefit of finite beings, allowing them to participate in a relationship with the source of infinite love, goodness, and value. God’s nature remains unchanged, while the creatures He made undergo the transformation and growth that result from knowing and experiencing Him.

Apparent Changes in God in the Bible

Throughout the Bible, there are numerous stories that seem to depict God changing His mind or reacting to new information. For instance, in the story of Jonah, God appears to reconsider His decision to destroy the city of Nineveh after the people repent. Similarly, in the account of Abraham interceding for Sodom, God appears to negotiate over the fate of the city, potentially changing His course of action.
How do we reconcile these stories with the idea that God cannot change His mind? The answer lies in understanding the literary nature of these narratives. The Bible often uses anthropomorphism—attributing human characteristics to God—as a way of making divine actions more relatable and understandable to readers. In these stories, God is depicted in a way that resonates with human experiences of decision-making and emotion.
These narratives are not meant to be read as literal descriptions of God’s nature. Instead, they use the language of human storytelling to communicate divine truths. Just as God is sometimes described with physical features like eyes, arms, or wings, these stories of God “changing His mind” are literary devices. They present divine actions from a human perspective, but they should not be interpreted as statements about God’s actual nature.

God’s Immutability: Unchanging Perfection

The theological concept of immutability states that God is unchanging in His essence, knowledge, and will. This immutability is a direct consequence of God’s perfection. If God were to change, it would imply either an improvement (which would suggest prior imperfection) or a decline (which would suggest a loss of perfection).
For a being that is already perfect, neither of these possibilities is consistent with its nature. Therefore, God’s immutability is a key attribute of His divine nature. He remains constant, reliable, and unwavering in His wisdom and actions, providing a firm foundation for faith and trust.

Conclusion: Finding Inspiration in Divine Consistency

As I explored this topic, I encountered others who shared similar perspectives on God’s unchanging nature. Their insights deepened my understanding and reaffirmed my belief in God’s perfection and consistency. Knowing that God cannot change His mind because of His omniscience brings comfort and assurance. If you’re interested in learning more about this topic, I encourage you to check out this thought-provoking video. You can find it here. It offers further insight into why God’s unchanging nature is essential to understanding His perfection.